1 4

One Craft Stop

Curated Valentine's Mystery Bag Gift Set

Curated Valentine's Mystery Bag Gift Set

$20.00 USD
$45.00 USD $20.00 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Can't decide on the perfect gift? Let us pick.

The Valentine's Edition Mystery Bag is hand-packed with a selection of our best-selling stationery, accessories and craft pieces, and it arrives in heart-print packaging with a Valentine's Edition label.

What to expect inside:

  • Cute, aesthetic stationery
  • Trendy lifestyle accessories
  • Craft supplies and stickers
  • A few sweet surprises

It would not be a mystery if we listed it exactly — and what goes in changes from bag to bag, so no two are the same.

Good for:

  • A Valentine's gift
  • Galentine's party favours
  • Treating yourself to an unboxing

Arrives ready to give — no wrapping paper needed. Hand-packed to order and shipped within 3-4 business days. Seasonal drop; once it sells out it will not be restocked until next year.

How your gift is made

Every order is assembled by hand, one at a time, after you place it — nothing is pulled off a shelf. It arrives wrapped and ready to give, with no price tags to peel off.

How long it takes

Most gifts are hand-packed and shipped within 3–4 business days. Custom scrapbooks are made to order and take 2–3 weeks before they ship.

Working to a date? Message us before you order and we'll tell you honestly whether we can make it.

View full details

  • Packed by hand, to order

    A real person assembles your gift after you order it. Nothing is pulled off a shelf.

  • Arrives gift-ready

    Wrapped and ready to give. No repacking, nothing to peel off.

  • Working to a date? Ask us first

    Message us before you buy and we'll tell you honestly whether we can make it — get in touch.

Secure checkout

  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa

In their words

What customers said after their gift arrived

Copied out exactly as they were written. Nothing here was written by us.

Got my package yesterday thank you so much ! Will definitely be ordering you a thousand times more .
Facebook message · Nov 2025

And under our posts:

  • “I've bought two of them can't wait for them to get here” — Jamie B.
  • “Can't wait to get mine!” — Shawnee R.
  • “I'm so excited to get more !!” — Bianca C.
500+

orders packed by hand so far

250+

customers have come back and ordered again

100+

orders from our most loyal customer alone

Ordered from us before? Reply to your order email and tell us how it arrived — good or bad. We read every one.

Made & packed
Hand-packed and shipped within 3-4 business days
  • 5 stars: 2 (40%)
  • 4 stars: 1 (20%)
  • 3 stars: 1 (20%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 1 (20%)
R
R.E.

I didn't care for this Valentines mystery bag. I get that all bags are a "mystery", but highly disappointed that it wasn't the same as all the other mystery bags that I have bought, I like the jewery and key chain, and stickers. The valentines mystery bag I recieved felt like I got her leftovers from other suprise boxes, I recieved chapstick, a random eye mask, some lotion, again it just felt like she went throught her bathroom and gave me the leftovers!

J
Jennifer

Would preferred more of a selection/ variety don’t feel that the contents added up to the price

E
Emely

Exactly as described. The quality exceeded my expectations and shipping was very fast. Will definitely order again.

A
A.H.

Both packs had similar items in alternate varieties minus one item being the same exact in both, cute little gift ideas, not exactly what I was expecting but close. Wish it were things I could have used more but am happy overall with purchase.

B
Barbra

Was cute but I was expecting something a lottle different! Although the valentines earrings are a hit

Curated Valentine's Mystery Bag Gift Set

$20.00