1 2

One Craft Stop

Premium Halloween Mystery Bag

Premium Halloween Mystery Bag

$20.00 USD
$30.00 USD $20.00 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.

The bigger Halloween bag, built around a handmade jewelry set.

Same idea as the standard bag: we pack from whatever we have finished that week, so the contents are a surprise. This one is put together around jewelry — pieces made to go together rather than a single charm thrown in.

We do not publish a fixed contents list. Every piece is made one at a time, so what is in yours changes from bag to bag.

The kinds of things we make

  • Handmade Halloween necklaces, earrings and shoe charms
  • Halloween-themed beaded pens
  • Handmade bracelets
  • Handcrafted bookmarks
  • Halloween keychains
  • Bedazzled magnets
  • Sticker sets
  • Candy treats

What we can promise

  • Everything inside is handmade here, not bought in and re-boxed
  • It is packed to order, after you buy it
  • It arrives gift-ready, with nothing to peel off
  • If it turns up damaged or short, send a photo within 7 days and we will replace or refund it

Hand-packed and shipped within 3-4 business days. A seasonal batch — once Halloween passes it will not be restocked until next year.

How your gift is made

Every order is assembled by hand, one at a time, after you place it — nothing is pulled off a shelf. It arrives wrapped and ready to give, with no price tags to peel off.

How long it takes

Most gifts are hand-packed and shipped within 3–4 business days. Custom scrapbooks are made to order and take 2–3 weeks before they ship.

Working to a date? Message us before you order and we'll tell you honestly whether we can make it.

View full details

  • Packed by hand, to order

    A real person assembles your gift after you order it. Nothing is pulled off a shelf.

  • Arrives gift-ready

    Wrapped and ready to give. No repacking, nothing to peel off.

  • Working to a date? Ask us first

    Message us before you buy and we'll tell you honestly whether we can make it — get in touch.

Secure checkout

  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa

In their words

What customers said after their gift arrived

Copied out exactly as they were written. Nothing here was written by us.

Got my package yesterday thank you so much ! Will definitely be ordering you a thousand times more .
Facebook message · Nov 2025

And under our posts:

  • “I've bought two of them can't wait for them to get here” — Jamie B.
  • “Can't wait to get mine!” — Shawnee R.
  • “I'm so excited to get more !!” — Bianca C.
500+

orders packed by hand so far

250+

customers have come back and ordered again

100+

orders from our most loyal customer alone

Ordered from us before? Reply to your order email and tell us how it arrived — good or bad. We read every one.

Made & packed
Hand-packed and shipped within 3-4 business days
  • 5 stars: 4 (67%)
  • 4 stars: 1 (17%)
  • 3 stars: 1 (17%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
A
April Morris

Everything in my mystery bad was great and my granddaughter enjoyed it also. She claimed the charm bracelet and spider items as quick as she could and my pumpkin magnet is my favorite. Thank you for our smiles and fun!

C
Carla Smith

Not worth $20. I got a beaded ink pen that's cute. A plastic spider ring. A nice leaf charm necklace that doesn't fit. (my neck is to large). Some candy but not really with the money

T
Teresa Lile

Want to order again next year :)

D
Dawn Hoover

Super happy with my mystery bag! I got the Halloween themed bag and the surprises were definitely worth the money. Will be buying again soon!!

A
Allison

adorable bag of really cool stuff!

A
Adrienne

Speedy delivery. The mystery bags contained a good variety of products. I ordered 3 different bags and received all different versions of the similar items included for each. Quality products and obvious time and care put into each

Premium Halloween Mystery Bag

$20.00